Phishing Simulations: How to Run Them Without Destroying Employee Trust

In Ireland, a recent report highlighted that over 80% of cyberattacks begin with a phishing attempt. For Irish SMEs, where resources are often stretched thin, a single successful phishing attack can lead to significant financial loss, reputational damage, and even regulatory fines under GDPR. While many businesses recognise the need to test their human firewall, the approach to phishing test employees often misses the mark, inadvertently fostering resentment rather than resilience. The goal of a phishing simulation best practices approach isn't to catch employees out, but to empower them with the knowledge and skills to identify and report real threats.

The Pitfalls of Punitive Phishing Tests

Traditional phishing simulations often adopt a 'gotcha' mentality. Employees who click on a simulated malicious link might face public shaming, mandatory re-training, or even disciplinary action. This approach, while seemingly designed to deter, can have several counterproductive effects:

• Erosion of Trust: Employees begin to distrust IT and security teams, viewing them as adversaries rather than allies. This can lead to a reluctance to report suspicious emails for fear of reprisal, even if they genuinely suspect a threat.
• Negative Culture: A punitive approach fosters a culture of fear and blame, which is detrimental to overall security. A strong security culture thrives on open communication, learning from mistakes, and collective responsibility.
• Limited Learning: When the primary outcome is punishment, the focus shifts from understanding why an employee fell for a phish to simply avoiding the next test. True behavioural change requires education and positive reinforcement.
• Gaming the System: Some employees might become overly cautious, reporting every email as suspicious, or worse, ignoring all security communications to avoid being targeted.

For Irish SMEs, where team cohesion is often a significant strength, undermining employee trust through poorly executed phishing tests can have far-reaching negative consequences beyond just cybersecurity.

Best Practices for Educational Phishing Simulations

To ensure your phishing simulation best practices genuinely enhance security awareness and build trust, consider these educational and supportive strategies:

1. Clear Communication and Transparency

Before launching any simulation, clearly communicate its purpose. Explain that the goal is to educate and improve collective security, not to punish individuals. Emphasise that everyone, from the CEO to new hires, is susceptible to phishing and that the tests are a learning opportunity. The NCSC Ireland consistently advises a proactive and transparent approach to cybersecurity education.

2. Focus on Education, Not Blame

When an employee falls for a simulated phish, the immediate response should be educational. Provide instant, constructive feedback that explains why the email was suspicious and how to identify similar threats in the future. This could be a short video, an infographic, or a brief, informative pop-up. Follow up with targeted, engaging training that reinforces key lessons.

3. Start Simple and Increase Complexity Gradually

Begin with easily identifiable phishing attempts and gradually introduce more sophisticated scenarios. This allows employees to build their detection skills over time, fostering confidence rather than frustration. Consider tailoring scenarios to common threats faced by Irish businesses, such as invoice fraud or credential harvesting specific to local services.

4. Positive Reinforcement and Recognition

Celebrate successes! Acknowledge employees who correctly identify and report simulated phishing emails. This could be through internal newsletters, team meetings, or small incentives. Positive reinforcement encourages desired behaviours and builds a more resilient security culture.

5. Integrate with Broader Security Awareness Training

Phishing simulations should not be a standalone activity. They are most effective when integrated into a comprehensive security awareness programme. Regular training on topics like strong passwords, multi-factor authentication, and data protection (especially relevant given GDPR and the upcoming NIS2 Directive for some Irish entities) provides a holistic defence.

Metrics That Matter: Beyond the Click Rate

While click rates provide a baseline, they don't tell the whole story. To truly measure the effectiveness of your phishing test employees programme, focus on these more insightful metrics:

• Reporting Rate: How many employees report suspicious emails (simulated or real)? A high reporting rate indicates a proactive security culture and trust in the security team.
• Resilience Score: Track the percentage of employees who don't click on simulated phishing links over time. This shows a direct improvement in detection capabilities.
• Time to Report: How quickly do employees report suspicious emails? Faster reporting can significantly reduce the impact of a real attack.
• Engagement with Training: Monitor completion rates and performance in follow-up training modules. Are employees actively engaging with the educational content?
• Reduced Real-World Incidents: Ultimately, the most important metric is a decrease in actual phishing-related security incidents. This demonstrates the programme's tangible impact on your organisation's security posture.

By focusing on these metrics, Irish SMEs can demonstrate a clear return on investment for their security awareness efforts and provide valuable insights to management and boards, aligning with good governance practices.

Free Resource: Download The Irish SME Cyber Survival Guide — 10 controls based on NCSC Ireland & ENISA guidance. Plain English, no jargon.

What This Means for Your Business

Cybersecurity is no longer optional for Irish businesses. navigating the complex cybersecurity landscape requires a pragmatic approach. Implementing phishing simulation best practices that prioritise education and trust over punishment is not just about compliance; it's about building a resilient workforce. A well-executed programme can significantly reduce your attack surface, protect sensitive data, and safeguard your reputation. It empowers your employees to be your first line of defence, turning a potential vulnerability into a formidable strength. This proactive stance also demonstrates due diligence, which can be crucial in the event of a data breach, both for regulatory bodies like the Data Protection Commission and for maintaining customer trust.

Ready to Strengthen Your Security Posture?

Pragmatic Security works with Irish SMEs to build practical, proportionate cybersecurity programmes that protect your business, satisfy regulators, and give you confidence. Whether you need NIS2 compliance support, a vCISO on retainer, or a one-off security assessment, we're here to help.

Book a free 20-minute strategy call today — no jargon, no hard sell, just practical advice from an experienced Irish cybersecurity professional.

Or contact us at [email protected] or call +353 870 515 776.

Take the Next Step

If phishing risks and employee security awareness is something you're thinking about, the best starting point is a structured conversation.

Book a free 20-minute call with our vCISO team. We work with Irish SMEs across every sector — no jargon, no scare tactics, just clear advice on what to do next.

Book Your Free 20-Minute Call →